Not Cooperating With Fear

The Night I Picked Up a Pen

On September 5th my wife sat across from me and told me how the last three days had been for her. I didn’t argue. I didn’t explain. I picked up a pen and wrote down what she said.

I’m not sure I had ever done that before. Not really. For most of our marriage, when she brought me something hard, part of me was already building the case for my side while she was still talking. I heard her words the way a defendant hears charges.

This time I just listened. And I wrote.

What She Said

Later I took those notes and put them back together as the letter she was really speaking to me. These are her words, as close as I could keep them.

For the last three days I’ve felt alone, hurt and frustrated. Every topic has turned into a struggle, and I’ve ended up feeling opposed by you. Instead of encouraging me, you’ve been discouraging and oppositional.

When I try to share an idea, I feel shut down. Then I get accused of interrupting or of trying to start a fight, and I’m left asking why. Your tone has felt aggressive. It’s been a double whammy: I come away discouraged, and I come away feeling unloved. My needs aren’t being met. I don’t feel love from you right now, and I don’t feel support.

Your behavior has been bad. You need to figure out what’s wrong with you and why you’ve been acting this way. I feel rejected. When I ask, “Are you my therapist now?” it’s because I don’t want to be analyzed. I want to be understood. I want to feel connected to you so I know I’m not alone.

It’s felt self-centered, like everything gets made about you. So I’m asking you plainly: can you be kind to me? Lately you’ve been unkind, and it hasn’t felt like you were thinking about me. It’s started to feel like a one-sided relationship.

That’s a hard letter to receive. Every line of it lands on something I’ve spent my life protecting.

Not Triggered

Here’s what I can’t fully explain. I received it.

Not the way I used to receive things, with my jaw tight and my rebuttal loading. I wasn’t triggered. I didn’t feel attacked. I read her words and something in me said, yes. She’s right. My behavior has been bad. I do need to look at what’s going on in me.

Accepting. Agreeing. No “yeah, but.”

I’ve been told some version of this for years, by her and by others. What was different wasn’t the message. It was the man hearing it. And I’ve been wondering ever since what changed, because that moment turned out to be a turning point. It opened a door to insights and growth I don’t think I could have reached any other way.

Love Is Always the Target of Fear

Two months later, on November 5th, I wrote another page of notes. I didn’t connect them to that night at first. Now I can’t read one without the other.

The first line says: learning humility on purpose. The posture that enables the hearing of God, the voice of the Holy Spirit.

I think that’s what happened in September. I didn’t only hear my wife. I heard God through her. And I could only hear either one because I wasn’t standing up to defend myself. Humility isn’t thinking less of myself. It’s being low enough, quiet enough, to actually receive what’s being said.

Further down I wrote: love is always the target of fear.

Love lives on hope, faith and trust. Fear works by turning those into doubt. Fear doesn’t bother with the things I don’t care about. It goes straight for what matters most, and in those three days it went straight for my marriage.

Then there’s a little circle I drew. Joy and love at the top, the primary emotions. Underneath, anger, fear and grief, the protector emotions. And below the circle, one word: identity.

That’s the whole mechanism, I think. The protectors stand guard over my identity. When my identity is shaky, any hard word feels like an attack on who I am, and anger shows up to fight it off. For most of my life I’ve let the protectors run the house. They kept me safe. They also kept love out.

But when I know who I am, when my identity rests in what God says about me and not in being right, there’s nothing to defend. The guards can stand down. Joy and love can come through. And a letter like hers becomes information, even a gift, instead of a threat.

Next to that I wrote: ruthless trust, ridiculous faith. And: ruach, breath. The same word the Hebrew uses for Spirit. He’s as near as my next breath, always available. I just have to stop holding mine.

The last line on the page is the one I keep coming back to. We are not punished for our sin. We are punished by our sin.

My defensiveness was never going to bring down some penalty from heaven. It was the penalty. It left her alone, and it left me on the opposite side of the table from the person I love most. John says it plainly:

There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear. For fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not been perfected in love. (1 John 4:18, ESV)

Fear has to do with punishment. I’d been living inside that punishment for years and calling it self-protection.

Not Cooperating

Things with my wife are amazing right now. I don’t say that lightly, and I don’t say it as if the work is finished.

But I’ve noticed something. Fear still shows up. It still takes aim at love. The difference is that I’m not cooperating with it anymore.

Fear needs my help to do its damage. It needs me to pick up the anger, defend the identity, make it about me. When I don’t, when I stay low and keep breathing and let the hard word land, fear has nothing to work with.

I wonder how many of the fights in my life were really just me cooperating with fear. I wonder what would have happened if I’d picked up a pen sooner.

I’m grateful I picked it up when I did.